History after Destruction: Case of Gaza’s Monuments
/
/
History after Destruction: Case of Gaza’s Monuments

In a recent interview on Al Jazeera, Shahidul Alam, the eminent photographer, activist, and founder of Dirk Picture Library (Dhaka)— while speaking on world conflicts— shared that people don’t learn from history because the official history, in most cases, is not the history of the people.

The people’s version of history can be found in ballads and legends that carry their stories of defiance, struggle and courage. In our times, social media as a popular expression has added a global dimension to the shared narratives of injustice and resistance. It is powerful and difficult to manipulate because it’s interactive and operates in real time. A testament to this was images of children in Gaza holding placards to thank students at Columbia University just as the protesters at Columbia faced police brutality, both became history via the internet.

How will history of the twentieth and twenty first century record the settler colonization of Palestine and the ongoing genocide of Gaza? Will it be brutally honest in stating that the massacre of 35,000 palestenians could have been avoided if UN Peacekeeping forces had intervened? Will it raise questions on why the very countries, that were once proud architects of Human Rights Convention and the Geneva Convention, have become complicit in crimes against humanity?

Another kind of destruction taking place in Gaza is one of cultural repositories like libraries, universities, colleges and historical sites that UNESCO is mandated to protect.

According to findings via satellite and eyewitness accounts, UNESCO has verified damage to 43 significant cultural sites that include 24 buildings of historical and artistic interest.

A major hub of art activity, the Shababeek for Contemporary Art, was razed to the ground by Israeli bombing, along with invaluable collection of 20,000 art works. This included 5,000 pieces that represented 30 years of the art practice of Sarhan, one of the founders of Shababeek for Contemporary Art. Earlier Eltiqa Group for Contemporary Art, another established visual arts space was also destroyed. Both these institutions offered community programming and art therapy for youth growing up amid the wars and blockades. Palestinians lost their prominent artist, Fathi Ghaben when he was kept from leaving Gaza to receive urgent medical care and we have news that popular artist Heba Zaqout was also killed in an airstrike. The human cultural capital of Gaza is increasingly at risk as intellectuals, academics, artists, poets and writers, among them 3 university presidents and 95 university professors, have been killed since October 2023.

In the last seven months neither of the major global electronic media nor the press have reported on the systematic destruction of museums in Gaza. The Al-Qarara Cultural Museum which housed a pottery collection from the Byzantine period, suffered serious damage. The Rafah Museum and Al-Mathaf, a national archaeology museum in the making, was also bombed and its contents lost forever. Israel is not only destroying historical sites but appropriating them for military use. Forensic Architecture has reported on the archaeological site of Blakhiyya, (identified as Anthedon Harbour, Gaza’s ancient seaport dated 800 BCE – 1100), has been largely damaged by Israeli airstrikes and military activities. The same is true of Mukheitim, the Byzantine Church from the fifth century, with its mosaic floors and Greek inscriptions which has been turned into a base for the Israeli military. Reports on the abuse and destruction of heritage are regularly issued on websites of concerned organizations like Forensic Architecture but the worldwide condemnation and extensive media debates that followed the destruction of the Banyan Buddhas in Afghanistan and looting of the Baghdad Museum, has yet to be seen.

The 1954 Hague Convention for the Protection of Cultural Property in the Event of Armed Conflict states that “damage to cultural property belonging to any people whatsoever means damage to the cultural heritage of all mankind, since each people makes its contribution to the culture of the world”. Furthermore, UN Conventions emphasize that cultural heritage is an important component of the cultural identity of communities, groups and individuals, and of social cohesion, so that its intentional destruction may have adverse consequences on human dignity and human rights will record for posterity that the failure to stop Israel and the active role of USA, UK and Germany is allowing this to take place will be an unforgivable loss of irreplaceable world heritage sites and the erasure of the tangible and intangible cultural heritage of the Palestinian people.

Niilofur Farrukh is an art interventionist based in Karachi. Her prolific five-decade career centers on decolonizing ways of viewing, reading, practicing, and writing about art and culture in Pakistan. In 2016, she co- founded Karachi Biennale Trust and as its CEO led four acclaimed editions of the Karachi Biennale through 2025. Since the 1990s, Niilofur’s art criticism—published across numerous platforms have brought modern and contemporary South Asian art and complex political ideologies from Pakistan into global view. She has three books to her credit: . A Beautiful Despair—The Art and Life of Meher Afroz(Lé Topical Printers, 2020), Pioneering Perspectives(Ferozsons,1998)and Pakistan’s Radioactive Decade: An Informal Cultural History of the 1970s (2019).(co-edited with John McCarry and Amin Gulgee, Oxford University Press). She also co-established NuktaArt: Pakistan’s Contemporary Art Magazine. She is currently writing her fourth book on early art histories of Karachi. As a curator, Niilofur approaches exhibitions as provocative spaces. In 2025 she curated … connecting internal and external time … the First Retrospective of Meher Afroz (2025). Her global engagements include being the current chair of the “Censorship and Freedom of Expression Committee” at International Association of Art Critics (AICA) and serving as a member of the International Institute of Public Art Prize at Shanghai University and being on the jury of AICA Young Critics Award.

Share this post

There are no comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Start typing and press Enter to search

Shopping Cart

No products in the cart.